Best Odds with Top Tote+ and Bet Back Offers!
Register at Australia's #1 Online Bookmaker!
Back A Winner!
Sign-Up to Australia's Fastest Growing Online Bookmaker!
Back Yourself!
Sign-up and start betting with Ladbrokes in 2 minutes!
Best Of The Best Odds!
Bet With Palmerbet and get Paid Top Fluc or Top Tote!
*Conditions Apply. Excl VIC, NSW, SA & WA. Gamble Responsibly

Flouting the whip rule to try and win a multi-million dollar race is nothing new … but, by any standards, Kerrin McEvoy’s use of the whip on the runner-up Tiger Moth in Tuesday’s Melbourne Cup arguably did both the rider and the industry a disservice.

Make no mistake, McEvoy is a great rider … one of Australia’s finest … but he would be hard pressed to convince most people that he was not aware of what he was doing when striking Tiger Moth, a young horse only having his fifth race start, a huge eight times more before the 100m mark than is allowable under the Rules Of Racing. (His whip use was reported as being thirteen times before the 100m and twenty-one times overall).

Maybe, he wasn’t aware but he was found culpable either way.

A $50,000 fine and a thirteen-meeting suspension came down heavily on McEvoy … but, beyond that, the penalties meant little of consequence in terms of the race result itself.

Tiger Moth still kept his second placing. Prince Of Arran, whose rider Jamie Kah had ridden within the rules, was less than a quarter of a length back in third place. Did McEvoy’s breach make a difference between second and third placing where, by the way, the prizemoney difference is a not unsubstantial $550,000?
That is an old argument … where no steward wants to go … so where does racing go from here with the whip issue.

Racing surely can’t leave it at that!

Clearly, as many participants have pointed out until they are blue in the face, the rule does not work in a number of aspects, either in ensuring that whip use is contained or, arguably, in ensuring that the justice is applied in the actual race results themselves.

So here, firstly, is a thought out of left field to offset both of those unhealthy and derisive factors.

If racing authorities are intent on staying with and using a ‘set number of strikes’ criteria … then set another threshold … a high number of strikes which if reached, by a jockey showing scant regard for the rule, would then lead to the disqualification of the horse in question.

Of course, that is a radical suggestion. Many will want to reject the idea and nobody would want to go that far if you didn’t have to … but that rule would both serve as a deterrent to those thinking of breaking the rule as well as bringing some justice to those who rode by the rule-book.

If that rule had applied on Tuesday, Tiger Moth would not have earned $1.1 million dollars and McEvoy would be paying his fine out of his pocket and not out of his stakes winning percentage.

Don’t you think that might have some effect on jockey’s future actions in the saddle?

Having said that there is, of course, a much better way for racing to undo the mess it has made of the whip rule.

Just do what most stakeholders want … abolish the rule altogether … but empower stewards with all the power they need to ensure that any form of whip abuse will be countered with severe penalties.

As always, quite often it a simple solution which solves a complicated problem.

In the old days, before authorities decided to pander to the perception of those least knowledgeable about the game, excessive use of the whip was always a breach of the rules, but rides in that respect were judged by seasoned stewards with criteria not necessarily involving any number count on actual whip strikes.

Irish trainer Ted Walsh’s probably put it best when he gave his view on the evolvement of the new whip rules back in 2019 in an interview in which took no prisoners on the whip issue. (Walsh is father of champion jumps jockey Ruby Walsh).

“Introducing the numbers was the biggest mistake they (the authorities) ever made because they backed themselves into a corner,” said Walsh. “Why do you have to go one, two, three, four, five, six, seven. There have been loads of good stewards over the years who would say … ‘oh, you misbehaved there, and they would give you a few days.

“Once they brought in the number, they had no choice (but to act) if you go over. It is like the speed limit.

“Don’t be pampering to the fellows who want to stop racing altogether. There is no use modifying anything. They won’t be happy until there is no racing.

Walsh then famously added, “Racing is what it is. If you don’t like racing, go and watch Peppa Pig.”

I’m with him!

* While Kerrin McEvoy and his ride on Tiger Moth was used as an example here, it must be noted that he is by no means a lone offender with regard to the whip rule … far from it … all the more reason for the whip rule to be reviewed with immediate effect.

*Existing customers only. 2nd Racing bet. Excl SA & WA. T’s & C’s apply. Gamble responsibly.
Featured News

Free Racing Bonus Bets and Offers

We take a look at the BIGGEST and BEST Free Daily Racing Offers and Betting Promotions from Australia’s leading online...

Alligator Blood’s trainer and owners part ways

Trainer David Vandyke will not be the trainer of star Queensland galloper Alligator Blood when the horse returns. David Vandyke...

Railway Stakes results and replay – 2020

View the results and replay for the 2020 Railway Stakes. The Railway Stakes was raced at Ascot racecourse on 21/11/2020....

Tokoriki Lad wins in unusual fashion

Punters watching the last race at the Sunshine Coast on Saturday did a quick double-take and then they still had...

The Gong results and replay – 2020

View the results and replay for the 2020 The Gong. The Gong was raced at Kembla Grange racecourse on 21/11/2020....

Ballarat Cup results and replay – 2020

View the results and replay for the 2020 Ballarat Cup. The Ballarat Cup was raced at Ballarat racecourse on 21/11/2020....

Star Queenslander Rothfire recovering well

For Rothfire, the Group 1 Golden Rose, back on September 26, was meant to be the final stepping-stone towards participation...

Connections turn down huge money for exciting stayer

Connections of exciting stayer Ain’tnodeeldun have turned down big money from Hong Kong interests. Co-trainer Sam Freedman has confirmed offers...

Racing officials reviewing use of whip

A study commissioned by the RSPCA has put the issue of whip use back in the spotlight after it found...

Stud career looms for Cox Plate winner

A stud career for Cox Plate winner Sir Dragonet is nearing although trainer Ciaron Maher will look to add a...

Winterbottom Stakes

The is a  race held at each year over and is known to be Western Australia’s premier sprint event. The race...

Australian Bookmaker Reviews

Which bookmaker should you bet with? We Review each of the leading online Australian Bookmakers and rate them in order...

Copyright © 2020 Just Horse Racing.
All rights reserved - Privacy Policy

Gamble Responsibly 18+
*State exclusions apply to some offers. Please check T&Cs of each offer with the bookmaker. All Offers Exclude NSW residents.
18+ Don't let the game play you. Stay in control. Gamble responsibly. Think! About your choices. Call Gambling Help on 1800 858 858 or visit or